EDDM is cheaper per piece; targeted mail is usually cheaper per relevant household. Every Door Direct Mail reaches every address on a postal route for a low postage price, but most of those homes do not need your service this month. Targeted, addressed mail costs more per card but goes only to households with a reason to call, such as a recent permit. Which one wins depends on how many of the households on a route actually need what you sell.
This guide explains how each works, the official USPS numbers, a simple way to compare them for your trade, and when to use each.
How EDDM works
According to the USPS EDDM page:
- You choose carrier routes in an online map tool and mail every address on them.
- Pieces are addressed to "Postal Customer"; no mailing list is needed.
- Retail EDDM postage is $0.26 per piece.
- The minimum is 200 pieces, and retail mailings are capped at 5,000 pieces per ZIP Code per day.
- EDDM pieces must be flat-size, so a standard 4 x 6 postcard does not qualify; you need a larger card.
- The route tool offers filters based on Census data such as age, household size and income, but you cannot select individual addresses.
Printing for EDDM-size pieces is a separate cost.
How targeted mail works
Targeted mail is addressed to specific households you choose: from a bought list, your own customers, or a trigger such as a building permit. Each card carries an address (and sometimes a name), so it costs more to mail than EDDM: as of the USPS price list effective October 4, 2026, a stamped First-Class postcard is $0.65, with lower commercial presorted rates for bulk mailers. You also pay for the list or data, unless it is your own.
Compare cost per relevant household, not per piece
The useful comparison is how much you spend to reach one household that might plausibly hire you. A simple formula:
Cost per relevant household = total cost ÷ (pieces mailed × share of recipients who need your service soon)
The share is the key unknown, and only you can estimate it for your trade and area. Two examples with illustrative numbers, not benchmarks:
| EDDM | Targeted (permit-triggered) | |
|---|---|---|
| Pieces | 2,000 | 200 |
| All-in cost per piece (illustrative) | $0.50 | $1.19 |
| Total cost | $1,000 | $238 |
| Share who need the service soon (your estimate) | 2% | 30% |
| Relevant households reached | 40 | 60 |
| Cost per relevant household | $25.00 | $3.97 |
Change the estimates and the answer can flip. For a service almost every household buys regularly (pest control, lawn care, HVAC tune-ups), the share on an EDDM route is higher and EDDM can win. For a service tied to a specific event (pool fencing, gutter guards after a re-roof, an addition's HVAC), targeted mail usually wins because the share on a random route is tiny.
The $1.19 figure is Permitnote's Starter per-card price, which includes printing and First-Class postage; the EDDM figure is a placeholder for postage plus printing. Get real quotes for your own comparison.
What targeted mail can reach that EDDM cannot
Permit data lets you choose households by what they are doing, not by who they are. In the last 30 days, as of Nov 18, 2026:
- San Antonio, TX issued 332 residential roofing permits. A gutter company mailing EDDM routes would reach those households only by chance.
- Nashville, TN issued 107 addition permits, up 18% on the month before.
- Sacramento County, CA issued 112 solar permits, spread across many ZIPs; the busiest was 95608.
Event-driven households are scattered across many routes, so the only efficient way to reach them is to address them individually. Browse current lists on the San Antonio roofing permits page and the Nashville home addition permits page.
When EDDM is the right tool
- Broad-need services: pest control, lawn care, cleaning, seasonal HVAC tune-ups.
- Neighborhood saturation around an active job or a dense customer cluster.
- Brand awareness in a compact service area where you want every household to know your name.
- Grand openings or new territories, where recognition matters more than precise targeting.
When targeted mail is the right tool
- Event-driven services: fences after pools, gutters after roofs, landscaping after new homes, HVAC after additions.
- High-ticket jobs, where one booked job pays for many cards.
- Scattered demand, where the right households are spread across many routes.
- Follow-up sequences, where you want to send a second or third card to the same household.
Using both
Many contractors combine them: targeted, permit-triggered mail for the households with a clear reason to call, and an occasional EDDM drop on the routes around active jobs to build recognition. Our direct mail planning guide covers cadence and tracking for both.
Design differences
EDDM requires a flat, so cards are larger (for example 6.25 x 9 or 6.5 x 11 inches or bigger), which gives more room for photos but costs more to print. Targeted postcards can use the 4 x 6 postcard rate. Either way, lead with a headline about the reader's situation and one clear offer. You can design your card free and preview it live.
FAQ
Is EDDM cheaper than targeted mail?
Per piece, yes: retail EDDM postage is $0.26 versus $0.65 for a stamped First-Class postcard. Per relevant household, targeted mail is often cheaper because it skips homes that do not need your service.
Can I use a 4 x 6 postcard for EDDM?
No. EDDM requires flat-size mail pieces, which are larger than a standard postcard. Check the USPS size requirements before printing.
Which is better for contractors, EDDM or a mailing list?
It depends on the service. EDDM suits services most households buy; targeted lists, especially permit-triggered ones, suit services tied to a specific project or event.